Running IS-IS over partially-meshed Frame Relay

From CT3

Jump to: navigation, search

By Ivan Pepelnjak

IS-IS routing protocol is not well-suited for partially-meshed IP subnets. Contrary to OSPF, which has evolved into a versatile protocol supporting multiple WAN models (broadcast, non-broadcast, point-to-multipoint), IS-IS supports only two types of inter-router connections: point-to-point links and broadcast multi-access subnets (typically used to model LAN interfaces).

The limitations of IS-IS network representation make it particularly hard to use on partially-meshed WAN (Frame Relay or ATM) networks. Generic optimal design uses point-to-point subinterfaces to convert each WAN virtual circuit (or DLCI) into a point-to-point router-to-router link. This design is functionally equivalent to point-to-multipoint OSPF network type but requires more logical interfaces and more complex router configuration. It’s also harder to add new neighbors or PVCs; while OSPF automatically discovers new connections and neighbors when operating in point-to-multipoint mode, you have to configure each subinterface and DLCI manually when using IS-IS.

If you configure IS-IS on multi-access WAN interface (main serial interface or multipoint subinterface), IS-IS models the multi-access interface as a LAN interface (equivalent to OSPF operating in broadcast mode). One of the routers is elected Designated Intermediate System (DIS) and generates Link State Packet (LSP) representing the IP subnet. IS-IS assumes full connectivity between all neighbors on the IP subnet, potentially resulting in unexpected behavior in partially meshed subnets.

More details

Related information

Additional Resources  

Configuring Configuring Cisco Routers for Integrated IS-IS (CISIS) course:

Building Scalable Cisco Internetworks (BSCI) course:

Other links:

Did you know?

  • NIL developed the first commercially available advanced technical training covering Cisco IOS implementation of IS-IS.
  • This course was for several years the only course available to Cisco's internal audiences and its Service Provider customers in Europe.
  • The IS-IS course developed by NIL later became part of Cisco's Service Provider training curriculum.
  • NIL's experts have helped several large Service Providers design and deploy IS-IS networks.
Personal tools


Main menu